Abstract
DNA Barcoding using Sanger sequencing is a popular technique for identifying species on a per specimen basis. However for larger projects, sequencing individual voucher specimens can be time and resource intensive and moreover is associated with high levels of sequencing failure and contamination. Oxford Nanopore Sequencing Technology (ONT) has emerged as a scalable alternative, capable of generating hundreds of DNA barcodes simultaneously using the portable, benchtop MinION sequencing device. In this study we aim to compare and contrast the sequencing outcomes of Oxford Nanopore R10 Flongle flowcells verses Sanger sequencing for DNA barcoding and produce a DNA barcode reference library. We demonstrate that DNA barcodes generated using ONT outperform those produced by Sanger sequencing in terms of recovery and sequence quality with lower rates of contamination. We then produced DNA barcodes for 146 seagrass associated marine invertebrate OTUs collected from four seagrass beds in Scotland, targeting COI and 18S V4 regions. Using both markers, we show the number of recovered OTUs was higher than if each marker was used in isolation and make use of degenerate and group-specific primer pairs to improve recovery. Furthermore we demonstrate how mapping ONT reads to pre-existing DNA barcodes can be used to reduce ambiguous basecalls and improve recovery of sequences from contaminated specimens. Overall this study informs prospective users intending to carry out multimarker DNA barcode projects using Oxford Nanopore Sequencing. Furthermore, we generated the first DNA barcode reference library for seagrass beds in Scotland to support future biomonitoring of these priority habitats.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Authorea |
| Number of pages | 20 |
| DOIs | |
| Publication status | Published - 25 Feb 2025 |
Bibliographical note
We would like to thank Fiona Ware and Sankurie Pye from the National Museums Scotland for assisting with the morphological ID of some specimens. We would also like to thank the following NGOs for facilitating sample collection and accommodation throughout fieldwork: Arran COAST, Seawilding, and the Skye Seas Survey Initiative.All sequence data is available on GenBank from the following accession numbers: XXXX-XXXX and BOLD systems under project code ERSSI (to be made available upon acceptance of the manuscript). Whole animals and DNA extractions are stored at the University of Aberdeen.
Funding
Funding for this project comes from the New Frontiers in Research Fund - Transformation 2020 (NFRFT-2020-00073) and the University of Aberdeen. Ross EG is supported by the QUADRAT Doctoral Training Program (DTP).
| Funders | Funder number |
|---|---|
| New Frontiers in Research Fund | NFRFT-2020-00073 |
| University of Aberdeen |
Keywords
- DNA Barcoding
- Biodiversity studies
- Oxford Nanopore Sequencing
- Marine Invertebrates
- Seagrass habitats