Abstract
Au Royaume-Uni, le fédéralisme a autant de partisans que de détracteurs: pour les uns, il s’agit d’une solution certes radicale, mais qui est tout à fait adaptée à l’asymétrie caractéristique du Royaume-Uni; tandis que pour les autres,c’est un loup déguisé en mouton. Ce ne serait là qu’uneautre idée (un complot?) provenant del’Europe visant àmettre fin à la vieille tradition britannique de souveraineté parlementaire. Or, les deux dernières décennies ont été le théâtre d’un important processus de dévolution au sein du système politique britannique, approfondissant d’autant plus l’influence européenne dans celui-ci, grâce notamment à la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme (CEDH) et à l’Eurozone. Les dernières années furent aussi caractérisées parle référendum sur l’indépendance de l’Écosse, et la décision de quitter l’Union européenne. Les questions constitutionnelles ont donc pris une importance renouvelée dans la vie politique du Royaume-Uni. Pour certains, cela signifie que le temps est venu de tenter l’expérience du fédéralisme, alors que pour d’autres il demeure absolument impraticable dans le contexte de l’agencement institutionnel britannique. Cet article se proposed’explorer les raisons pour lesquelles le fédéralisme est une idéequi,bien que minoritaire,continue de susciter un intérêt au seinde la classe politique du Royaume-Uni. Mais nous verrons également pourquoi certains problèmes auxquels ferait face un Royaume-Uni fédéral semblent, à maints égards, insurmontables.
In the United Kingdom, federalism has as many supporters as it does detractors: for some, it is a radical solution, but one that is well suited to the asymmetry that characterises the United Kingdom; for others, it is a wolf in sheep's clothing. It is seen as just another idea (a plot?) from Europe aimed at ending the old British tradition of parliamentary sovereignty. However, the last two decades have seen a significant process of devolution within the British political system, further deepening European influence in it, thanks in particular to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the Eurozone. The last few years have also been marked by the referendum on Scottish independence and the decision to leave the European Union. Constitutional issues have therefore taken on renewed importance in the political life of the United Kingdom. For some, this means that the time has come to try federalism, while for others it remains completely impracticable in the context of the British institutional framework. This article explores the reasons why federalism is an idea that, although supported by a minority, continues to attract interest among the political class in the United Kingdom. For some, this means that the time has come to try federalism, while for others it remains completely impracticable in the context of the British institutional framework. This article explores the reasons why federalism is an idea that, although supported by a minority, continues to attract interest among politicians in the United Kingdom. But we will also see why some of the problems that a federal United Kingdom would face seem, in many respects, insurmountable.
In the United Kingdom, federalism has as many supporters as it does detractors: for some, it is a radical solution, but one that is well suited to the asymmetry that characterises the United Kingdom; for others, it is a wolf in sheep's clothing. It is seen as just another idea (a plot?) from Europe aimed at ending the old British tradition of parliamentary sovereignty. However, the last two decades have seen a significant process of devolution within the British political system, further deepening European influence in it, thanks in particular to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the Eurozone. The last few years have also been marked by the referendum on Scottish independence and the decision to leave the European Union. Constitutional issues have therefore taken on renewed importance in the political life of the United Kingdom. For some, this means that the time has come to try federalism, while for others it remains completely impracticable in the context of the British institutional framework. This article explores the reasons why federalism is an idea that, although supported by a minority, continues to attract interest among the political class in the United Kingdom. For some, this means that the time has come to try federalism, while for others it remains completely impracticable in the context of the British institutional framework. This article explores the reasons why federalism is an idea that, although supported by a minority, continues to attract interest among politicians in the United Kingdom. But we will also see why some of the problems that a federal United Kingdom would face seem, in many respects, insurmountable.
| Translated title of the contribution | Is there a federal solution to the British constitutional conundrum? |
|---|---|
| Original language | French |
| Title of host publication | Cinquante déclinaisons de fédéralisme |
| Subtitle of host publication | Théorie, enjeux et études de cas |
| Editors | Felix Mathieu, Dave Guénette, Alain-G Gagnon |
| Place of Publication | Montreal |
| Publisher | Presses de l’Université du Québec |
| Chapter | 30 |
| Pages | 403-414 |
| Number of pages | 11 |
| ISBN (Electronic) | 9782760554023 |
| ISBN (Print) | 9782760554016 |
| Publication status | Published - Sept 2020 |
Fingerprint
Dive into the research topics of 'Is there a federal solution to the British constitutional conundrum?'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.Cite this
- APA
- Standard
- Harvard
- Vancouver
- Author
- BIBTEX
- RIS