Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Infant mental health services for families of maltreated pre-school children in foster care (BeST?): a single-blind cluster-randomised, multicentre, phase 3 clinical- and cost-effectiveness trial

  • Helen Minnis* (Corresponding Author)
  • , Karen Crawford
  • , Robin Young
  • , Philip Wilson
  • , Manuela Deidda
  • , Matt Forde
  • , Susanne Millar
  • , Alex McConnachie
  • , Kathleen Boyd
  • , Emma McIntosh
  • , Dennis Ougrin
  • , Marion Henderson
  • , Christopher Gillberg
  • , Gary Kainth
  • , Fiona Kainth
  • , Edmund Sonuga-Barke
  • *Corresponding author for this work
  • University of Glasgow
  • NSPCC
  • Glasgow Health and Social Care Partnership
  • Queen Mary University of London
  • University of Strathclyde
  • University of Gothenburg
  • King's College London

Research output: Working paper › Preprint

Abstract

Background Maltreated children are at high risk of negative psychosocial outcomes. Interventions targeting their foster carers are modestly effective. No previous RCT has targeted birth families of maltreated children in foster care.

Methods In this single-blind, cluster-randomised, phase 3 trial (Registration: BeST? Clinicaltrials.gov: NCT02653716), families with a 0-5-year-old child entering foster care in Glasgow or London were randomised 1:1 (secure web portal; researchers masked; stratification by site with minimisation) to the New Orleans intervention model (NIM) or social work services-as-usual (SAU). NIM offers infant mental health assessment (~3 months) and treatment (6-9 months) to birth families and children in foster care, aiming to improve child mental health and recommend return home or adoption. The principal outcome measure of child mental health was the 20-item Strengths and Difficulties Total Difficulties (SDQ-TD) Scale at 2.5 years post study entry (high scores indicating poorer child behaviour).

Findings Between January 2012 and July 2021, 382 families (488 children) were recruited: 22 families were later deemed non-eligible leaving 360 families (439 children; 47.0% female). Follow-up continued until December 2023 when the trial was fully powered: 286 families (149 NIM; 137 SAU, 367 children) were followed up at 2.5 years (79.4%). Intention-to-treat analysis found no intervention effect of NIM: Mean (SD) SDQ-TD NIM 11.5 (7.6); SAU 11.1 (7.2); adjusted mean difference (NIM-SAU) 1.4; 95% CI (-0.63, 3.53); p=0.17. Girls randomised to NIM had higher SDQ-TD scores at 2.5 years wrt SAU: Interaction p=0.0217; adjusted mean difference 2.96; (0.12, 5.82); p= 0.042 - adjusted mean difference in boys was 0.12; 95% CI (-2.82, 3.09). Of 52 SAEs (21 NIM; 31 SAU), none were intervention related. Within the trial time horizon, NIM is not cost-effective costing £10,592 per child versus £4557 for SAU.

Interpretation Contextual challenges meant only 66.4% of eligible families received NIM. Despite no measured within-trial effects for SDQ-TD, higher scores in girls randomised to NIM could indicate either poorer mental health or, conversely, a process of recovery. Follow-up is therefore essential.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherResearch Square
Number of pages28
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 11 Aug 2024

Bibliographical note

Thanks to the children, and their birth and foster families, who took part in this study. Thanks to NIHR PHR for continuing to support BeST? 363 despite major unexpected challenges. Thanks to Cathie Greig, Adelle Neave, Anni Molloy and Juliana Lovato for recruitment and retention; Sharon Graham, Anne Swartz and Fiona Lettice for offering their expertise by experience; Udita Iyengar and Lynn McMahon for Trial Management; Irene O’Neill, for trial administration; David Walker, John McHugh and Mairi Warren for data management; our Trial Steering Committee (Professor David Cottrell, Dr Christine Puckering, Ms Fiona Lettice and Professor Stavros Petrou), our Data Monitoring and Ethics Committee (Professor Sheila Bird, OBE; Dr Shubulade Smith, CBE, Dr Helen McTier), our research nurses (Efisia Sais, Caroline Carlisle, Charlotte Mceleney, Kirsteen Paterson and Nadia Palma) for persistent and supportive data collection and to our social work and judicial colleagues for their strong partnership throughout. This paper represents independent research in part funded by the NIHR Maudsley Biomedical Research Centre at South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust and King’s College London. The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.

Funding

National Institute for Health Research (PHR 12/211/54) 

UN SDGs

This output contributes to the following UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

  1. SDG 3 - Good Health and Well-being
    SDG 3 Good Health and Well-being

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Infant mental health services for families of maltreated pre-school children in foster care (BeST?): a single-blind cluster-randomised, multicentre, phase 3 clinical- and cost-effectiveness trial'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this