Abstract
Many opposition parties in electoral-authoritarian regimes identify as democracy movements. I ask: what ideologies do they publicly express? The first-glance answer is 'democratic ones', but there are many theories of liberal democracy, and they say little about living under or indeed confronting authoritarian regimes. I analyse the public messages of two such democracy movements: Chadema (Tanzania) and the Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC, in Zimbabwe). I argue that they each articulate a homegrown vision of democracy in which they adapt democratic theory to make sense of their electoral-authoritarian circumstances. They do so by articulating that theory through the 'populist logic' conceptualized in the discourse-theoretic perspective. I call them anti-authoritarian (and democratic) populisms. Previous research has overlooked the distinctiveness of these ideologies because it has adopted concept configurations which invisibilize them. I argue that there are reasons to expect there to be a wider body of anti-authoritarian populisms articulated by democracy movements in electoral-authoritarian regimes in Africa, and indeed, worldwide.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Pages (from-to) | 866-887 |
| Number of pages | 22 |
| Journal | Government and Opposition |
| Volume | 59 |
| Issue number | 3 |
| Early online date | 12 Dec 2023 |
| DOIs | |
| Publication status | Published - Jul 2024 |
Bibliographical note
Open Access via the CUP agreementThanks to the editors, anonymous reviewers, Sara Dorman and Luke Melchiorre for their feedback on previous versions of the paper. Thanks to Kucaca Phulu, Thilo Schöne and those who wish to remain anonymous for their insightful and invaluable discussions on CCC ideology. Thanks to McDonald Lewanika for his help navigating numerous online archives and contacting other members of Zimbabwe's democracy movement. Thanks to Deogratias Munishi and Patrick Ole Sosopi for the insightful discussions of Chadema's contemporary political thought. Thanks, more widely, for all of those who showed me hospitality and rendered me assistance in my fieldwork and subsequent research on Chadema in Tanzania.
Data Availability Statement
No data availability statement.Keywords
- Africa
- anti-authoritarianism
- democracy
- electoral authoritarianism
- populism