The Tougher the Better: An Economic Analysis of Increased Payment Thresholds on the Performance of General Practices

Yan Feng; Ada Ma; Shelley Farrar; Matt Sutton

doi:10.1002/hec.3022

The Tougher the Better: An Economic Analysis of Increased Payment Thresholds on the Performance of General Practices

Yan Feng, Ada Ma, Shelley Farrar, Matt Sutton

OFFICE OF HEALTH ECONOMICS

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We investigate whether and how a change in performance-related payment motivated General Practitioners (GPs) in Scotland. We evaluate the effect of increases in the performance thresholds required for maximum payment under the Quality and Outcomes Framework in April 2006. A difference-in-differences estimator with fixed effects was employed to examine the number of patients treated under clinical indicators whose payment schedules were revised and to compare these with the figures for those indicators whose schedules remained unchanged. The results suggest that the increase in the maximum performance thresholds increased GPs' performance by 1.77% on average. Low-performing GPs improved significantly more (13.22%) than their high-performing counterparts (0.24%). Changes to maximum performance thresholds are differentially effective in incentivising GPs and could be used further to raise GPs' performance across all indicators

Original language	English
Pages (from-to)	353-371
Number of pages	19
Journal	Health Economics
Volume	24
Issue number	3
Early online date	5 Jan 2014
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1002/hec.3022
Publication status	Published - Mar 2015

Bibliographical note

Acknowledgements
This paper was carried out whilst Yan Feng was a PhD student in the Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen. The PhD was funded by the Institute of Applied Health Sciences, University of Aberdeen PhD studentship. The paper was written up when Yan was working in the Office of Health Economics (OHE). We would like to thank Luís Silva Miguel and the audience for their comments on this work during the tenth European Health Economics Workshop. We also thank Hugh Gravelle, Nancy Devlin, Stephen Morris, Marjon van der Pol, Robert Elliot and Mandy Ryan for their comments and suggestions. The Health Economics Research Unit (HERU) is funded by the Chief Scientist Office of the Scottish Government Health Directorates (SGHD). The views in this paper are those of the authors and not HERU, SGHD or OHE.

Keywords

financial incentives
quality and outcomes framework
general practitioners

Access to Document

10.1002/hec.3022Licence: Unspecified

Shelley Farrar
- School of Medicine, Medical Sciences & Nutrition, Health Economics Research Unit - Research Fellow
- Institute of Applied Health Sciences
Person: Academic Related - Research

Cite this

@article{82015e9a67af44d3a1ba9e119aed5fa1,

title = "The Tougher the Better: An Economic Analysis of Increased Payment Thresholds on the Performance of General Practices",

abstract = "We investigate whether and how a change in performance-related payment motivated General Practitioners (GPs) in Scotland. We evaluate the effect of increases in the performance thresholds required for maximum payment under the Quality and Outcomes Framework in April 2006. A difference-in-differences estimator with fixed effects was employed to examine the number of patients treated under clinical indicators whose payment schedules were revised and to compare these with the figures for those indicators whose schedules remained unchanged. The results suggest that the increase in the maximum performance thresholds increased GPs' performance by 1.77% on average. Low-performing GPs improved significantly more (13.22%) than their high-performing counterparts (0.24%). Changes to maximum performance thresholds are differentially effective in incentivising GPs and could be used further to raise GPs' performance across all indicators",

keywords = "financial incentives, quality and outcomes framework, general practitioners",

author = "Yan Feng and Ada Ma and Shelley Farrar and Matt Sutton",

note = "Acknowledgements This paper was carried out whilst Yan Feng was a PhD student in the Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen. The PhD was funded by the Institute of Applied Health Sciences, University of Aberdeen PhD studentship. The paper was written up when Yan was working in the Office of Health Economics (OHE). We would like to thank Lu{\'i}s Silva Miguel and the audience for their comments on this work during the tenth European Health Economics Workshop. We also thank Hugh Gravelle, Nancy Devlin, Stephen Morris, Marjon van der Pol, Robert Elliot and Mandy Ryan for their comments and suggestions. The Health Economics Research Unit (HERU) is funded by the Chief Scientist Office of the Scottish Government Health Directorates (SGHD). The views in this paper are those of the authors and not HERU, SGHD or OHE.",

year = "2015",

month = mar,

doi = "10.1002/hec.3022",

language = "English",

volume = "24",

pages = "353--371",

journal = "Health Economics",

issn = "1057-9230",

publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",

number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Tougher the Better

T2 - An Economic Analysis of Increased Payment Thresholds on the Performance of General Practices

AU - Feng, Yan

AU - Ma, Ada

AU - Farrar, Shelley

AU - Sutton, Matt

N1 - Acknowledgements This paper was carried out whilst Yan Feng was a PhD student in the Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen. The PhD was funded by the Institute of Applied Health Sciences, University of Aberdeen PhD studentship. The paper was written up when Yan was working in the Office of Health Economics (OHE). We would like to thank Luís Silva Miguel and the audience for their comments on this work during the tenth European Health Economics Workshop. We also thank Hugh Gravelle, Nancy Devlin, Stephen Morris, Marjon van der Pol, Robert Elliot and Mandy Ryan for their comments and suggestions. The Health Economics Research Unit (HERU) is funded by the Chief Scientist Office of the Scottish Government Health Directorates (SGHD). The views in this paper are those of the authors and not HERU, SGHD or OHE.

PY - 2015/3

Y1 - 2015/3

N2 - We investigate whether and how a change in performance-related payment motivated General Practitioners (GPs) in Scotland. We evaluate the effect of increases in the performance thresholds required for maximum payment under the Quality and Outcomes Framework in April 2006. A difference-in-differences estimator with fixed effects was employed to examine the number of patients treated under clinical indicators whose payment schedules were revised and to compare these with the figures for those indicators whose schedules remained unchanged. The results suggest that the increase in the maximum performance thresholds increased GPs' performance by 1.77% on average. Low-performing GPs improved significantly more (13.22%) than their high-performing counterparts (0.24%). Changes to maximum performance thresholds are differentially effective in incentivising GPs and could be used further to raise GPs' performance across all indicators

AB - We investigate whether and how a change in performance-related payment motivated General Practitioners (GPs) in Scotland. We evaluate the effect of increases in the performance thresholds required for maximum payment under the Quality and Outcomes Framework in April 2006. A difference-in-differences estimator with fixed effects was employed to examine the number of patients treated under clinical indicators whose payment schedules were revised and to compare these with the figures for those indicators whose schedules remained unchanged. The results suggest that the increase in the maximum performance thresholds increased GPs' performance by 1.77% on average. Low-performing GPs improved significantly more (13.22%) than their high-performing counterparts (0.24%). Changes to maximum performance thresholds are differentially effective in incentivising GPs and could be used further to raise GPs' performance across all indicators

KW - financial incentives

KW - quality and outcomes framework

KW - general practitioners

U2 - 10.1002/hec.3022

DO - 10.1002/hec.3022

M3 - Article

SN - 1057-9230

VL - 24

SP - 353

EP - 371

JO - Health Economics

JF - Health Economics

IS - 3

ER -

The Tougher the Better: An Economic Analysis of Increased Payment Thresholds on the Performance of General Practices

Abstract

Bibliographical note

Keywords

Access to Document

Fingerprint

Profiles

Shelley Farrar

Cite this